Cobit 2019 Maturity Assessment Tool Xls «Verified | SECRETS»
The COBIT 2019 Maturity Assessment Tool is primarily provided through the ISACA COBIT 2019 Design Guide Tool Kit . This Excel-based toolkit facilitates the assessment of 40 governance and management objectives using a CMMI-aligned capability and maturity model. 1. Key Features of the XLS Tool Multi-Tab Workflow : Includes specific tabs for Design Factors (to tailor the governance system) and a Governance System Canvas to visualize results. RACI Charts : Dedicated tabs for roles like Audit or IT management allow for clear assignment of "Responsible" or "Accountable" for each of the 231 COBIT practices. Gap Analysis : Automates the comparison between "Current Capability" and "Target Capability" scores (1–5 scale). 2. Maturity & Capability Levels (0–5) The tool uses a scale adapted from CMMI to measure how well processes perform: Level 0 (Incomplete) : Ad hoc, work may not be completed. Level 1 (Initial) : Unpredictable and reactive; goals not fully met. Level 2 (Managed) : Projects are planned and measured at a project level. Level 3 (Defined) : Enterprise-wide standards provide guidance across projects. Level 4 (Quantitative) : Data-driven performance improvement with predictable objectives. Level 5 (Optimizing) : Continuous improvement and stable platform for innovation. 3. How to Use the Assessment Tool
COBIT 2019 Maturity Assessment Tool (Excel) – Overview & Implementation Guide 1. Purpose of the Tool The COBIT 2019 Maturity Assessment Tool (typically an Excel spreadsheet) enables organizations to evaluate the capability level of their governance and management processes based on the COBIT 2019 framework . Unlike traditional "maturity" models (e.g., CMMI’s 1–5), COBIT 2019 uses a Capability Level approach (0 to 5) aligned with ISO 15504. This tool helps answer:
How well does our process perform? What is the gap between current and target capability? Where should we invest improvement efforts?
2. Key Components of the Excel Tool A well-structured COBIT 2019 maturity assessment Excel file usually contains these sheets: | Sheet Name | Description | |------------|-------------| | Instructions | How to use the tool, rating definitions, and scoring rules | | Process List | Full list of 40 COBIT 2019 governance/management processes (e.g., APO01, BAI03, DSS02) | | Capability Levels | Criteria for levels 0 (Incomplete) to 5 (Optimizing) based on process attributes (PA) | | Assessment Input | Rows for each process, columns for PA1 (Process performance), PA2 (Work product mgmt), PA3 (Process definition), PA4 (Process deployment), PA5 (Measurement), PA6 (Optimization) | | Rating Scale | N – Not achieved, P – Partially achieved, L – Largely achieved, F – Fully achieved | | Gap Analysis | Visual heatmap or conditional formatting to highlight gaps | | Dashboard | Charts (radar, bar) summarizing capability by domain (EDM, APO, BAI, DSS, MEA) | | Improvement Plan | Action items, ownership, target dates for moving to next level | 3. How to Perform the Assessment (Step-by-Step) Step 1 – Define Scope Select which COBIT 2017 processes (or 2019 core model) are in scope. For example: Cobit 2019 Maturity Assessment Tool Xls
Focus on DSS (Deliver, Service, Support) for an IT operations review. Include all 40 for enterprise-wide governance assessment.
Step 2 – Gather Evidence For each process attribute (PA1–PA6), collect objective evidence:
Policies, process workflows, KPIs, audit reports, role assignments, continuous improvement records. The COBIT 2019 Maturity Assessment Tool is primarily
Step 3 – Rate Each PA Using the built-in rating scale (N/P/L/F), determine achievement:
N = <15% achieved P = 15–50% L = 50–85% F = >85%
Then the tool automatically converts these to a numeric capability level for the process: Key Features of the XLS Tool Multi-Tab Workflow
Level 0 – All PAs incomplete Level 1 – PA1 ≥ L Level 2 – PA1 ≥ F and PA2 ≥ L Level 3 – PA1–PA3 ≥ F Level 4 – PA1–PA4 ≥ F Level 5 – PA1–PA6 ≥ F
Step 4 – Identify Gaps The tool highlights any PA where current < target. For example, if target = Level 3, but PA3 (Process definition) is only “P”, that’s a gap. Step 5 – Create Action Plan The improvement plan sheet auto-suggests (or allows manual input) actions based on low-rated PAs. 4. Example Excerpt from the Tool (Text Representation) | Process ID | Process Name | Target Level | PA1 | PA2 | PA3 | PA4 | PA5 | PA6 | Achieved Level | Gap | |------------|--------------|--------------|-----|-----|-----|-----|-----|-----|----------------|-----| | APO01 | Mgmt framework | 3 | F | F | P | N | N | N | 2 | -1 | | BAI03 | Solutions build | 4 | F | F | F | L | N | N | 3 | -1 | | DSS02 | Service request | 2 | L | P | N | N | N | N | 1 | -1 | PA1 = Process performance, PA2 = Work product management, PA3 = Process definition, PA4 = Process deployment, PA5 = Measurement, PA6 = Optimization 5. Benefits of Using the Excel Tool